AI Capabilities Showdown: A Detailed Analysis
This summarizes the key findings from a comprehensive evaluation of various AI capabilities across different smartphone brands and AI platforms. The assessment focuses on AI Eraser functionality, background noise reduction in videos, camera-based AI features, and general AI assistant performance.
I. AI Eraser Functionality: Samsung and Pixel Lead the Pack
The AI Eraser test evaluated the ability of various phone models to seamlessly remove unwanted objects from photos, with increasing levels of difficulty.
Top Performers (3 points):
- Samsung Galaxy: Consistently
"absolutely nailed it"
across all difficulty levels, making it"the clear winner of this AI eraser showdown."
Its ability to handle complex erasures, even with intricate details like hands and rings, was highlighted. - Google Pixel: Performed exceptionally well in the initial rounds,
"absolutely nailed it"
like the Galaxy. However, its performance was hindered in the final round due to an"ethical thing"
where"Google won't let you edit parts of people."
Despite this, it would have been"right up there with Samsung"
otherwise. - Xiaomi: Showed significant improvement, moving from a quirky
"Why remove the dog when I can transform it into mandarins?"
in round one to"actually nailed it this time"
in round two and strong results in round three.
Mid-Tier Performers (1-2 points):
- Vivo: Demonstrated usable results, scoring
"slightly better than the iPhone"
in round one and showing some competence in round three, despite a confusing outcome in round two ("I don't even know what that is"
). - OnePlus and Oppo: Consistently delivered
"nearly identical"
results, which were"not bad but there's still room for improvement"
in round one. They produced"brass knuckles GTA style and an extra finger"
in round two and"replaced my shades with a brand new pair of clear glasses"
in round three, making their results"somewhat usable."
- iPhone: Showed inconsistent performance. While it
"did remove our balloon buddy"
in round one,"the table looks a bit off."
Its"intelligence wasn't so intelligent"
in round two, as it"just cut my hand in half."
In the final round, it"basically turns me into a bootleg elastig girl,"
indicating it"should step it up too because right now it's not a serious contender."
Bottom Performer (0 points):
- Honor: Faced persistent
"network error"
issues in the initial rounds, leading to it being"out of this round"
and completely flopping. Even when it eventually worked, the results were highly unsatisfactory, producing"pudding or maybe something that I shouldn't describe on camera."
The reviewer concluded that Honor"clearly lost the AI eraser battle they really need to get that sorted ASAP."
II. Background Noise Reduction: iPhone Takes the Crown
This test specifically evaluated the ability of phones to remove background noise during video recording. Only the iPhone, Galaxy, and Pixel offered this functionality.
Winner:
- iPhone:
"Wiped out all background noise in both scenarios"
(cafe and traffic). The voice came through"super clear and surprisingly not super robotic,"
despite being"a bit quiet."
This performance"honestly surprised us considering how AI focused the Galaxy and the Pixel are."
Runner-Up:
- Samsung Galaxy: Was
"much louder but it let some background noise sneak in."
Additionally,"you can also hear a few artifacts in the voice too."
Last Place:
- Google Pixel: Volume-wise was
"close to the iPhone but there's still a lot of background mumbling and on top of that my voice sounds very muffled."
III. Camera-Based AI Features (Visual Intelligence): Gemini Live vs. Apple Intelligence
This section compared the real-time visual intelligence capabilities of Gemini Live (on Android) and Apple's Visual Intelligence (which leverages ChatGPT).
- Key Differentiator:
"The biggest difference is that the Apple's visual intelligence doesn't support real life conversations whereas Gemini does and not only that but it can also see you through its camera in real time."
- Similarities in Performance: Both platforms achieved
"four out of five correct,"
indicating they are"both at a great level."
They successfully identified a cactus and provided care tips. They also correctly recognized and summarized the book "Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep," and provided purchasing options. - Areas for Improvement: Both struggled to correctly identify the exact model of a Samsung Galaxy S25, consistently guessing it was an S23.
- Caveat for Apple Intelligence: The reviewer notes,
"if we're being completely honest Apple Intelligence does pass its questions off to Chat GPT so can we really call it Apple Intelligence?"
IV. General AI Assistant Performance: Gemini Dominates Siri
This final section directly compared the general AI assistant capabilities of Gemini and Siri.
- Gemini's Superiority: Gemini
"absolutely demolishes Siri"
with a score of 5 to 1. - Image Generation: Gemini
"came through and generated the chaotic image we asked for,"
while Siri"just pulled some random stock photos."
- Device Comparison: Gemini provided a
"full breakdown of keyspec similarities and differences"
for a device comparison, whereas Siri"just handed over Google search links."
- Music Playback: Gemini
"nailed it again opened YouTube music and played the right track,"
while Siri"also opened YouTube Music but played some random song with friends in the title."
- Information Retrieval: Gemini
"did its homework and actually pulled info about our latest video"
when asked about the subject of a YouTube video. - Siri's Limitations: Siri frequently resorted to providing Google search links or irrelevant results, highlighting its significant limitations compared to Gemini.
- Even Ground: Both successfully identified a song playing, with Gemini passing the mic to Google Assistant and Siri sending it to Shazam.
V. Overall Conclusions
- AI Eraser: Samsung is the
"go-to"
for the best AI eraser. Pixel is strong but limited by ethical considerations. Xiaomi is a surprising contender. - Noise Reduction: The iPhone
"takes the crown"
for background noise reduction in videos. - Camera-Based AI: Both Gemini Live and Apple Intelligence (with ChatGPT's help) are
"on pretty equal ground."
However, Gemini's ability to engage in"actual conversation"
makes the experience"smoother."
- General AI Assistant: Gemini
"absolutely wipes the floor with Siri." "There's just no contest."
This briefing highlights the significant variations in AI capabilities across different platforms and devices. While some excel in specific areas, others demonstrate broader, more comprehensive AI integration.
Smartphone AI Showdown: Features and Performance Compared: FAQ
Which smartphone AI is best for removing unwanted objects from photos?
Samsung's Galaxy and Google's Pixel phones consistently performed best in the AI Eraser tests, effectively removing distractions like a balloon dog or a remote control with minimal noticeable artifacts. Xiaomi also showed strong results in later, more difficult tests. Vivo and iPhone showed some capability but often left subtle imperfections, while OnePlus and Oppo had mixed results. Honor struggled significantly with network errors and poor output.
How do different smartphone AIs compare in background noise reduction for videos?
The iPhone demonstrated superior performance in background noise reduction, effectively eliminating ambient sounds like cafe chatter and traffic while maintaining clear voice quality. The Galaxy was louder but allowed some noise to pass through, and the Pixel, despite similar volume to the iPhone, produced muffled voices and significant background mumbling.
What are the key differences between Gemini Live and Apple's Visual Intelligence in camera-based AI features?
Both Gemini Live (available on Android devices) and Apple's Visual Intelligence are capable of identifying objects, providing information, and summarizing text from images. However, Gemini Live has a significant advantage in supporting real-time, conversational interactions and can "see" through the camera in real-time. Apple's Visual Intelligence, while competent, does not support real-time conversations and reportedly passes its questions off to ChatGPT.
How do Gemini and Siri compare in handling user requests and general AI capabilities?
Gemini consistently outperformed Siri in a direct comparison of general AI capabilities. Gemini successfully generated images based on descriptions, provided detailed comparisons of devices, correctly played specific songs, and accurately retrieved information from recent web content. Siri, in contrast, often pulled random stock photos, provided generic search links, played incorrect songs, and required passing tasks to other applications like Shazam.
Which AI performed poorly or had notable limitations in the tests?
Honor's AI consistently performed poorly across all AI Eraser tests, often encountering network errors and producing unusable results. Apple's AI, particularly for photo editing, was noted as needing improvement and not being a serious contender. Google's Pixel, while excelling in basic object removal, had an "ethical" limitation that prevented it from editing parts of people in photos.
Can smartphone AI capabilities be adjusted for better results?
Yes, the source mentions that many of these phones allow users to tweak effects and intensity levels for AI features. The tests were conducted with settings cranked to 100% to evaluate extreme performance, implying that with user adjustments, even better results could be achieved for specific scenarios.
Were there any surprising outcomes in the AI tests?
One surprising outcome was the iPhone's strong performance in background noise reduction, given the general AI focus of competitors like the Galaxy and Pixel. Xiaomi also delivered surprisingly strong results in the AI Eraser tests, despite an initial bizarre outcome in the first round.
What were the overall winning AIs in each category tested?
- AI Eraser: Samsung's Galaxy was identified as the clear winner.
- Noise Reduction: The iPhone took the crown.
- Camera-Based AI: Gemini Live and Apple Intelligence (with ChatGPT's help) were on par, but Gemini Live offered a smoother, more conversational experience.
- General AI Assistant: Gemini absolutely demolished Siri.
